Serving
Customers
From a Single Oven to a Community Staple
It all started with a simple dream: make pizza the way it was meant to be made — with patience, pride, and premium ingredients. Green lantern pizza was founded right here in McFarland, Wisconsin, by people who believed that great food brings people together.
Over the years, our recipes have stayed true to our roots while our menu has grown to serve every craving. From classic margheritas to bold specialty pies, every pizza that leaves our kitchen carries the same love we put in on day one.
We source vegetables, meats, and dairy from trusted local and regional suppliers to keep every bite as fresh as possible.
Our pizzas are baked on stone decks at high heat, creating that signature crisp crust and beautifully melted cheese every time.
Every dough ball is hand-stretched, every sauce is made from scratch, and every pizza is checked before it reaches your table or door.
What Drives Everything We Do
Our mission is simple: bring people together over extraordinary pizza made with integrity, craft, and care.
Quality First
We never cut corners. Every ingredient is chosen with care, and every pizza meets our high standards before leaving the kitchen.
Community First
We're proud to be a McFarland institution. We support local events, partner with local suppliers, and give back whenever we can.
Sustainability
We use eco-friendly packaging, minimize food waste, and work with suppliers who share our commitment to a greener tomorrow.
Happiness on Every Plate
We believe great food creates great memories. Our goal is to put a smile on your face — slice after slice.
A Legacy Built Slice by Slice
From humble beginnings to a beloved McFarland landmark — here's how Green lantern pizza came to be.
Opening Our Doors
Green lantern pizza opened its first location on Siggelkow Rd in McFarland, WI, with a single stone oven, a family recipe, and a dream to feed the neighborhood.
Best Pizza in Dane County
Five years in, we earned our first "Best Local Pizza" award from the Dane County Dining Guide — a milestone that fueled our passion to keep improving.
Bringing Pizza to Your Door
We launched our own delivery service, bringing Green lantern pizza right to McFarland's doorsteps — fresh, hot, and on time, every time.
New Flavors, Same Heart
We expanded our menu to include craft calzones, loaded pasta, and seasonal specialty pies — giving our regulars exciting new reasons to visit.
Online Ordering & Catering
We launched our full online ordering platform and a dedicated catering service, making it easier than ever to enjoy Green lantern pizza wherever you are.
Your Neighborhood Pizzeria
Over 20 years later, we're still here — same address, same love for great pizza, and the same commitment to the McFarland community that trusted us from day one.
The People Behind Every Perfect Slice
Our passionate team brings decades of culinary experience, warmth, and dedication to every shift — and every pizza.
Marco started Green lantern pizza with a family recipe and a fire in his heart. With 25+ years of crafting pizza, he still hand-stretches every dough ball on busy nights.
Sophia trained in Naples and brings authentic Italian technique to McFarland. She leads menu development and ensures every sauce, every topping is always exceptional.
James keeps the engine running smoothly — from supplier relationships to delivery logistics. His behind-the-scenes work ensures every order arrives perfectly.
Anika is the reason every guest leaves with a smile. She leads our front-of-house team and makes sure every visit to Green lantern pizza feels like coming home.
Want to be part of our team? We're always looking for passionate people.
View Open PositionsThe Principles That Guide Every Decision
At Green lantern pizza, our values aren't just words on a wall. They're the foundation of every pizza we make, every customer we serve, and every decision we take.
Order NowCraftsmanship
We take pride in the art of pizza-making and never stop pursuing a better crust, a richer sauce, or a more balanced topping combination.
Integrity
We're honest about our ingredients, our pricing, and our promises. What you see on the menu is exactly what you get.
Passion
We genuinely love making pizza. That love shows in every detail — from hand-rolled dough to the final garnish on your plate.
Community
McFarland is our home. We invest in local events, hire locally, and always look for ways to give back to the community that supports us.
Responsibility
We care about the planet. From eco packaging to reducing waste, we're committed to running a business that's good for more than just profits.
Innovation
We honor tradition while embracing new ideas — from seasonal specials to better delivery tech — always finding ways to serve you better.